Skip to content
Menu
Lucky's Bookshelf
  • Browse
  • About
Lucky's Bookshelf

Book Review: Losing the Nobel Prize by Brian Keating

Posted on January 22, 2019April 9, 2022
Topics: Natural Sciences, Nonfiction

Rating: 8.0/10.

A scientist arrives in Antarctica to make observations with a telescope, then gets a call that his dad is dying, and has to leave. This book has two intertwined parts: one telling the author’s story with cosmology and the second explaining problem in modern physics research and the Nobel prize. The title is a kind of double-entendre: the author loses the Nobel prize (after a close call), and the Nobel prize should be lost (abolished).

The first part starts off with Galileo observing the sky with his telescope, and generations of cosmologists trying to understand the structure of the universe and our place in it. In the 20th century, cosmic microwave background (CMB) is observed, and a lengthy scientific debate ensued over what happened in the big bang — was there an exponential inflation period or was it steady state? I didn’t follow all of the technical details, but in the end the author builds a telescope “BICEP” to measure the “B-mode polarization” of the microwave background. In 2014, they seemingly made a Nobel-prize-worthy discovery, but subsequently it was found that the signals were actually due to cosmic dust.

The second part talks about problems with the Nobel prize. It is only limited to three people, which doesn’t reflect modern physics research, where projects are collaborations of thousands of people. It encourages unhealthy competition and is very random, since many groups are working on similar things, but only the group that got there first gets all the glory. Finally, it requires recipients to be alive, which is bad since there’s often a decades gap between when something is theorized to when it’s experimentally verified.

From this book it seems that experimental physics is really technically difficult, competitive, and stressful, and indeed, in the middle of the book, a project leader commits suicide. One thing that struck me as odd was how the author seemed extremely fixated on winning the Nobel prize; this is in stark contrast to most interviews with Fields medalists, who concentrated on doing their best possible research, with prizes and awards as a mere afterthought.

See more reviews on Amazon.com

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Twitter

Most similar books:

A Short History of Quebec by John Dickinson and Brian Young The Second Kind of Impossible by Paul Steinhardt The Trouble with Physics by Lee Smolin The Demon-Haunted World by Carl Sagan

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Enjoying these books?

Join our mailing list to receive weekly book reviews!

No spam, unsubscribe at any time

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Subjects

  • Meta (2)
  • Topics (227)
    • Arts and Music (12)
    • Business / Finance (25)
    • Canada (11)
    • China (17)
    • Current Events (8)
    • Data Science / ML (8)
    • Economics (11)
    • History (27)
    • Indigenous (9)
    • Linguistics (17)
    • Mathematics (5)
    • Medicine / Health (14)
    • Natural Sciences (20)
    • Philosophy (15)
    • Self-Help / Career (12)
    • Social Sciences (12)
    • Software Engineering (3)
    • Startups (12)
    • World (22)
  • Type (244)
    • Classics (18)
    • Nonfiction (162)
    • Novels / Fiction (29)
    • Textbooks (36)

Lucky’s Bookshelf is a participant of the Amazon Affiliates Program.

©2023 Lucky's Bookshelf | Powered by SuperbThemes & WordPress